Offensive Rookie of the year winner

Alfred Morris 1 votes
RG3 - 2 Vote
Winner RG3

I dunno what the vote composition was but I changed mine to RG3.  RG3 had the bigger influence on his team and he had better stats than Wilson - Christian.
I looked at some stats and i think that Morris is the right pick - Maceo

MVP Winner

Adrian Peterson - 3 Votes
Peyton Manning - 1 Vote
Winner: AP

Defensive Player of the Year Winner

J.J Watt - Consensus

Coach of the Year winner

Coach of the Year winner
Chuck Pagano ( 3 Votes )
Leslie Frazier ( 1 Vote )

The 2012 Pick 'Em results and Rules Explanation

Results

Sadly, the regular season of football has come to an end, and with that so does this years family Pick 'Em.  We had a great, competitive season where everyone managed to make it above .500!  Here are the results:

1st - Christian 172-84 (.672)
2nd - Bishop 166-90 (.648)
       Tammie 166-90 (.648)
3rd - To be determined
4th - Herb 166-90 (.648)
5th - Maceo 142-104 (.555)

Rules Explanation

 As you can see, Herb, Bishop, and Tammie all tied with a record of 166-90, so why are Bishop and Tammie listed at 2nd while Herb falls to 4th?  Earlier in the season Herb missed a game (Week 6, Steelers @ Titans).  Ultimately everyone picked this game incorrectly, but it was determined that missing games would be one of the criteria for a breaking a tie.  The game went down as a loss for everyone, but since Herb missed one game and the rest missed none, Bishop and Tammie win the tie breaker.

"Overtime"

 We've never had a tie before, so we have some options for determining how this works.  Input would be awesome and is encouraged.  The tied individuals could simply pick games by playoff round until one emerges victorious, with a final tie breaker at the end (should no one take the lead) being a coin flip.  Alternatively, the three people who are -not- involved in the tie breaker can select the games in the round that will determine the tie breaker.  This is an option because there are always an even number of games in the playoff rounds until you reach the Superbowl.  An uneven number ensures that both parties pick the same or a winner is determined during that round of playoffs.

Finally, secret choices should be considered.  Players may be tempted to drag this out for 5 weeks, believing that they have a better chance of at winning a coin flip.  However, we didn't do this for the regular season so its up to what you guys think.

Prize

 Although the winner gets all of the prize, I determined that I will follow in last year's winner's footsteps (Herb) and split the money.

1st Prize - $50

2nd Prize - $30

3rd Prize - $20 

Defensive Rookie of the year

Luke Kuechly ( 2 vote ) Maceo, Christian.

Although you spelled his name wrong :P.

MVP Vote

Cast your MVP Vote to see who the family votes for the 2012 - 2013 MVP
Peyton Manning ( 1 Vote )  Bishop
Adrian Peterson ( 2 Votes ) Maceo,Tammie
Too early to tell, but I'm going with either Brady or AP.  Really depends on how the rest of the year plays out.